Is the Pakistan/Taliban Deal The Death Knell For Pakistan? - Instablogs
Is the Pakistan/Taliban Deal The Death Knell For Pakistan?
Incognito , Boca Raton: Feb 20 2009
Made Popular Feb 20 2009
Pakistan :

Is the Pakistan/Taliban Deal The Death Knell For Pakistan?

Does anyone truly believe that the Taliban will lay down their weapons and agree to live in peace in the Swat Valley? Do they truly believe that once they have conquered, so to speak, that region they won’t continue to fight for the Islamization of the rest of Pakistan, and elsewhere?

The recent peace deal inked between the Pakistani government and the Taliban is a coup for those who want to render Pakistan like Afghanistan was, under the rule of the Taliban; ruling through fear, intimidation and violence. The Taliban have held the northwest region of Pakistan captive for years, and the Pakistani government has essentially thrown the citizens who live there under the proverbial bus, with this agreement. It’s nothing more than appeasement. The violence is not going to stop, even when their demands for instituting shariah law are met, and the people there are going to suffer even more.

Civil rights activist and lawyer, Athar Minallah commented

“This is simply a great surrender, a surrender to a handful of forces who work through rough justice and brute force.Who will be accountable for those hundreds of people who have been massacred in Swat? And they go and recognize these forces as a political force. This is pathetic.”

Although they claim female schooling won’t be banned, I am convinced that will eventually change. It has to. The Taliban will never allow women to be educated, they never did when they ruled Afghanistan, why should it be any different in Pakistan? A leopard does not change its spots, and the Taliban will never change their ‘dark-ages’ mentality.

And that’s evident in what happened a few days ago. Even though the Swat Taliban announced a 10-day cease-fire, it didn’t last long. It seems militants don’t care much for cease-fires. Musa Khan Khel, a Geo TV reporter was shot and killed while covering the peace deal. He was also beheaded in what seems to be the popular, barbaric Taliban method du jour.

Hamid Mir, Geo TV Chief said

“There were 32 bullets fired on Musa Khan. There were groups who wanted Musa Khan to give up journalism so that they don’t come into picture. But he did not fall prey. Instead he got into aggressive reporting and exposed all of them. We are not at all going to run away from such threats. We are going to continue to do our work from Swat. Such killings are not going to slow down our spirit.”

The Taliban will continue to embrace the violence they are so accustomed to, by killing anyone who they oppose, or who doesn’t fall into their fundamentalist line.

When will people realize that appeasement does NOT work? It never has and never will.

Add Images and Videos
Close X
Recommended Tags or Keywords
Search by Tags or Keywords
Selected Media ( You can Upload only Six media )
Sorry no picture found for this combination of tags. Try to search minimum number of tags at once
1 Stars
Zara
Sydney, Australia
This is a very troubling position being taken by the Pakistani government. I am sure they know a lot more than one as ignorant of the complexities as I am, but still, it sure seems like capitulation. How do you explain this to the teachers who will no longer be able to teach and the little girls who will no longer be able to go to school?
2 Stars
Incognito
Boca Raton, United States
well, they claim they won’t close the girls schools, but that seems unlikely, especially after they burned down so many of them.
(Global Perspectives)
1 Stars
Jamie
Vancouver, Canada
This is what should have been expected from the weak government in Pakistan - they have tried it before. The people are tired of being terrorized but I am not sure this is the solution they expect it to be. It was the father making the deal but it is the son who controls the fighters - does the father have sufficient control over the son? Giving terrorists what they want simply encourages more terrorism.
1 Stars
Incognito
Boca Raton, United States
Jamie,
No the moderate Dad obviously has no control over the son, because extremists have no self-control. They are hard wired for violence. And I agree, this is going to give them carte blanche, because they will see it as a weakness.
(Global Perspectives)
1 Stars
Munty
Muscat, Oman
The taliban are humans, of course they do have some backwards practises and beliefs that are abhorred, but when peace occurs, the extremists political strength will die down, and the more moderates will take control. It has always happened that way and always will.
3 Stars
Steven Gary
melbourne, Australia
I somewhat agree with you Munty,

I think the extremists are the biggest attention seekers in the world. They agressively provoke retaliation, which panders to their popular political appeal (as so called martyrs)and struggling victims in the world.They provoke their own victimisation. and relish the power it gives them.

Maybe moderation should be encouraged with the hopes of good things to come and true peace,but not at its expense by short sighted so called peace deals that are no more than political expediencies.
(Global Perspectives)
2 Stars
Incognito
Boca Raton, United States
Munty, I don’t believe extremists/terorists are humans. Their minds have been warped through their religious fanaticism. And they will never allow the moderates to co-exist. Afghanistan under Taliban rule remained prehistoric. That’s not going to change. And if you read any of the jihad websites, you will know this is true. They can not abide moderates. they consider them as much Kuffars as they do non-Muslims.
(Global Perspectives)
2 Stars
Incognito
Boca Raton, United States
StevenGAry,

The moderates are as scared of causing waves as anyone else, because they too will be singled out and killed. Again, read any of the jihad websites...
(Global Perspectives)
1 Stars
Vijay
Kota, India
Yes,It is and with this deal,I think Pakistan lost all hope to return to normalcy.
1 Stars
Incognito
Boca Raton, United States
Vijay,

I hope not, but it seems very likely.
(Global Perspectives)
4 Stars
Gokhan
Buffalo, United States
Westerners will not change what is happening in the Muslim world. Muslims will have to do it themselves after they get sick and tired of the repression and interference in their daily lives by their Mullahs.
4 Stars
Adam
Perth, Australia
You are right my friend... but make sure they don't export their sick view of humanity to the rest of the world. Cut off all aid and weapons to those theocratic countries. Let them wallow in their poverty and ignorance. Just make sure that they are contained within their borders and are not allowed to export their vile ideology via immigration to the rest of the world.
(Global Perspectives)
1 Stars
Incognito
Boca Raton, United States
Gokhan,

You are absolutely right, no-one but those who live under that oppression can do anything about it, but it will be a fight to the death, because the extremists won’t give up without a fight. And will the people have the stomach for it. Time will tell.

Adam,

That’s not going to happen, though.
(Global Perspectives)
0 Stars
Bandar
Riyadh, Saudi Arabia
i believe Sharia law is the best way to spred peace, prosperity and welfare in the society. Those who criticised are the enemy of Islam and Pakistan. one of the graet example 'SAUDI ARABIA'where thersis sharia law and not even a 1% crime exists,comparing America with world highest crime ratio.
1 Stars
Incognito
Boca Raton, United States
Bandar,

Really? Is that why they jail and punish rape victims? Surely, if it’s such a great system, why are women even raped in your country? I’d think people would be so evolved and spiritual it wouldn’t even enter their minds to rape, because they are so pious.

You are terribly wrong, but you have a right to believe what you believe.
(Global Perspectives)
1 Stars
Ryan
Wellington, New Zealand
Experience in the past Pakistani locals and many peace agreements signed in the areas adjoining to Afghan border has not been good. Usually the Pak Taliban use these peace deals as breathing space to increase training and recruiting to eliminate any local leaders who might be more moderate and to capture more land. But Pakistan need to understand that this will end in chaos for them first. but let's hope for the common sense to prevail this time and something better will come out this time.
1 Stars
Incognito
Boca Raton, United States
Ryan,

Sadly, it won’t. The Taliban and other extremists have imperialistic aims. It’s just going to spread.
(Global Perspectives)
3 Stars
Rajesh
Abu Dhabi, United Arab Emirates
I agree it doesn't benefit man kind, neither it is beneficial to girls and people who enjoy music. Another appalling example of religion dictating how people should live.

we all saw and know that Taliban give most muslims a bad name. Closing girls schools, leaving their own female population uneducated reflects on the male psyche of the Taleban who work against the teachings of Islam. We have to separate the issues and understand that Sharia Law isn't a law applicable to society
2 Stars
Incognito
Boca Raton, United States
Rajesh,

The Taliban and any extremist give Muslims a bad name, unfortuntely. But they are the most visible, and active.

”Taleban who work against the teachings of Islam”

They don’t see it that way, though.. and that’s a major problem.
(Global Perspectives)
1 Stars
Zain
Islamabad, Pakistan
i am a Pakistani and being a muslim i favor the sharia law. It should be implemented in rest of the Pakistan as well. As Pakistan is an Islamic country, no reason why there should not be Islamic sharia law. I can guarantee that with sharia law crime will decrease dramatically in this region
1 Stars
Incognito
Boca Raton, United States
Zain,

I appreciate your opinion, however, not everyone in Pakistan feels the same, so why should they have to live under Shariah, simply because a few would prefer to?

Perhaps there might be less crime, but at what expense? Sad to have to live in fear. There will always be criminals even in Islamic States. You still have men raping women in Saudi Arabia, and sadly the woman is oftentimes punished the same as the man. What kind of justice is that?
(Global Perspectives)
1 Stars
Dave
Dublin, Ireland
Pakistan didn't learn from the past experiences - neither it seems to in near future. A deal with a fanatic organization like Taliban... I will call it nothing more than a backward step offering concessions to a backward fanatic ppl....an organization that is scared of educated girls...i wonder how a peace deal with such group will be successful!!!
1 Stars
Incognito
Boca Raton, United States
Dave,

It won’t.
(Global Perspectives)
Add your Comment